REEL TRUTH with Serena Whitney
March 19, 2010 – 6:58 am | One Comment

The Curse of the Mr. N.I.C.E. Guy
I laid there still in the darkness praying It didn’t sense I was awake. Struggling for air, I had managed to relief myself from my claustrophobic situation by taking …

Read the full story »
Features

Editorials, lists, columns, and opinions.

Interviews

Killer Film talks with filmmakers from every genre.

News

What’s happening in the movie world.

Reviews

Picking apart Theatrical, DVD, and Blu-Ray releases.

Videos

Trailers, clips, shorts, and original content.

Home » Reviews, Spotlight, Theatrical

Watchmen Review #2

Submitted by Erin Bennett on March 6, 2009 – 3:45 am3 Comments

watchmenstillIt gave me chills. Simply put. Never have I sat through a movie of this multitude so attentively and so completely dumbfounded. To be completely honest, I sat down in my uncomfortably rickety recliner of a chair with a haze of oncoming disappointment sneaking into the forefront of my mind. Movies like this, adaptations from books, comic books, anything of the sort, are never expected to be exactly as you envisioned it. It just doesn’t happen. But, as soon as the first scene began and Rorschach’s harsh, raspy voice encircled the darken theatre my doubt and apprehension lifted. Zack Snyder and his crew obviously did their homework.

The movie follows a sequence of events that happen after a self-proclaimed and American government promoted hero, the Comedian, is found dead on the concrete directly below his loft. A vigilante by the name Rorschach, a fellow cohort of the Comedian’s back when masked heroes were still excepted as a form of protection in the society, attempts to pull together his old team, the Watchmen, to warn them of their friend’s untimely demise and that they too may be the victim of another insolent killing. Of course, the plot becomes much more complex than I’m letting off, but to honestly put such a brilliancy into words is beyond my capabilities. You simply understand it; never comprehend it.

The one thing that blindsided me and left me staggering was the use of direct quoting from the graphic novel, and also the freeze-frame images. Literally, I could hold my book up to the screen and see the panels coming to life; Rorschach leaping into the comedian’s busted window, Dan Dreilberg’s inner depression swallowing him whole as he sits slumped against the walling of his lair, his costume hanging behind him like an haunting memory after Rorschach‘s unannounced visit, simple things that the normal movie-goer would never take a second glance at leave die-hard fans with their mouths agape and minds blown. The meticulous detail displayed within the movie is astounding. It all looked as if it had been blown up directly from the novel and structured exactly the same 

The opening credits were complete perfection, also. All the background, all the set-up you could possibly need was condensed into an easy to swallow pellet to the tune of “Times are Changing” by Bob Dylan(rightly so). We see the processor’s of The Watchmen, The Minutemen, in action; both their rising and decline in public popularity. It was a seamless  because it never interfered with the rest of the movie; there were no unnecessary cuts to the past to help explain America’s sudden distaste and distrust of masked protectors, it is simply implied.

There is a lot of complaining going around about some of the cuts the movie made that were important within the graphic novel, which is generally expected and accepted with the terms of taking on such an extensive project . I’m honestly very forgiving when it comes to things like this what with a time limit of about three hours to hold a audience’s attention span long enough to get an entire comic book series interpreted into film. Minor character developments and back-story’s that don’t particularly make a difference within the movie is not as blasphemous as it seems. All I have to say on that particular matter other than telling those few whiners to get off their computer and change their shirt and maybe call up Jenny Craig is that, one; the keyword is adaptation. And number two, Synder condensed, flawlessly might I add, an entire graphic novel into, hit or miss, two hours and forty minutes. Pivotal scenes were shown and executed just right and still withheld the true spirit Watchmen has embodied for millions of fans. If that isn’t good enough, then hug your George Lucas pillow, it’s the only comfort you’ll receive.

So, before I start to really gush, let me sum this up. I loved it. I love Zack Synder’s filming style; I felt the dramatic zooming in and out and the slow motion during certain action scenes fit perfectly with the graphic novel’s ambience. He also focused in on the symbolism that needed and used it to his advantage like the infamous smiley face. Not to the point of bashing you repeatedly in the head with it, but enough to help you realize the importance. The ending had me laughing, just like the graphic novel and I stood up from my grimy blue chair blown away and feeling fulfilled. This movie held its own to all the hype it has received and I believe I will need to see it at least five more times before it officially sinks in.

Remember, once you realize what a joke everything is, being the Comedian is the only thing that makes sense.

Rating: ★★★★★

  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • del.icio.us
  • Technorati
  • Google
  • Sphinn
  • Mixx
  • Fark
  • Furl

Tags: , , ,

3 Comments »

  • cj says:

    I agree with Jon about this movie. Nothing like the Dark Knight!

    [Reply]

  • Donny Broussard says:

    Maybe it’s just me, but I’m so tired of hearing about The Dark Knight that it hurts my ears every time I hear the title. I dug the movie, but it’s not the holy grail.

    I’m a fan of the Watchmen book and I went into this movie hoping that I’d get at the very least a decent adaptation of the material. I was blown away by how closely the film followed the book. I loved this movie, and maybe that’s just me talking from a fanboy’s perspective, but either way I agree with Erin. There is no such thing as a perfect movie (except for Jaws, Chasing Amy, The Thing, and Close Encounters of the Third Kind), but Watchmen came close. I loved it! Do I wish they wold have put in some of the stuff they missed? Yes. But I also understand that when you make a movie that running time is a big issue so I’m willing to overlook the missing parts.

    I think people need to stop looking for reasons to hate movies. I think it’s absurd to beg for a filmmakers to make a film that follows the book, and then bitch about when they do just that. Or picking out small things like the fact that some of the music in the film wasn’t to your liking (sorry Jon, your still my boy). I could come up with a handful of flaws in The Dark Knight, but it’s a waste of my time, and if I did that I might start a revolution amongst those that look upon TDK as yet another translation of the Bible

    [Reply]

  • daniel says:

    Jaws, Chasing Amy, The Thing, and Close Encounters of the Third Kind are these the only films you think are ‘perfect’ ??

    [Reply]

Leave a comment!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This site uses Gravatars for comments. If you want to have your own avatar shown, head on over to Gravatar.com. Otherwise, you'll just get what we give you.